Uploaded image for project: 'Logging analytics'
  1. Logging analytics
  2. LOG-1114

Need for "ReadWriteMany" access on storage when deploying on Kubernetes?

XMLWordPrintable

      Hello,

      today when deploying Log with OOM, the PersistentVolumeClaim need the "ReadWriteMany" (or "RWX") capability:

       

      $ kubectl get pvc -n onap | grep log-
      onap-log-log-elasticsearch                                                       Bound     onap-log-log-elasticsearch                      1Gi        RWX                                                        3h21m

       

      $ kubectl get pvc -n onap | grep pomba 
      onap-pomba-pomba-data-router Bound onap-pomba-pomba-data-router 2Gi RWX 3h34m 
      onap-pomba-pomba-elasticsearch Bound onap-pomba-pomba-elasticsearch 1Gi RWX 3h34m
      

       

       

      According to Kubernetes Documentation (https://kubernetes.io/docs/concepts/storage/persistent-volumes/#access-modes), ReadWriteMany stands for "the volume can be mounted as read-write by many nodes".

      That means that a particular PVC needs to be read and written from many pods. That also means that your code takes that into account and do the work to avoid write at the same place at the same time.

      An issue on RWX mode is that most "official" storage driver from Kubernetes doesn't support it (13 over the 19 drivers doesn't support it, espacially OpenStack, Amazon and Google storage classes).

      It's then very hard in a lot of case to use Log.

       

      If the needs is that the volume can be mounted as read by many nodes and write by one node (which seems to be the case), RWO (ReadWriteOnce) should be sufficient and is supported by all drivers.

       

      in the effort to deploy ONAP for gating on public cloud (one the priority of El Alto), using storage classes (and if possible RWO access) is very important.

       

      Can you verify that RWO is sufficient and if yes, I can submit a Gerrit review to move your access needs to RWO.

            sdesbure sdesbure
            sdesbure sdesbure
            Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            3 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: